teenager in back of rideshare car

PA Supreme Court Rules if Putting Children in an Uber or Lyft Without Car Seats is a Crime

By Zachary D. Campbell, Lawyer at Metzger Wickersham

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has decided the case of Commonwealth v. Howard, holding that a person does not commit the crime of Endangering the Welfare of a Child (“EWOC”) by allowing a child to ride in a rideshare vehicle (i.e. Uber, Lyft) without a car seat.

It’s important to note that parents can still be found guilty of EWOC if there are other facts presented (i.e. the parent was aware that the driver had been driving unsafely). However, a defendant cannot be found guilty simply because a child was not in a car seat while riding in a rideshare vehicle even if the car later gets into an accident.

Commonwealth v. Howard

In the case of Commonwealth v. Howard, a mother was charged and convicted after she placed her three-year-old daughter in the back seat of a rideshare vehicle. According to the lower court’s decision, the child was not placed in a car seat and the vehicle was unfortunately involved in a crash. Additionally, no one in the vehicle was wearing a seat belt as well.

After the crash, the mother was charged with recklessly endangering another person and endangering the welfare of children. At the trial, the mother was convicted by a judge on both counts based on her failure to secure her daughter in a car seat. The mother received one year of probation. She then appealed her conviction.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld the lower court’s conviction of endangering the welfare of children. The Court found there was enough evidence presented that the mother placed her child in the vehicle for hire without any safety restraints. However, the Court found there was insufficient evidence to uphold the conviction of recklessly endangering another person. In reversing that conviction, the Court noted, “This Court is cognizant of the dangers that could result from a parent’s failure to utilize proper child passenger restraints for their children. However, while [the mother’s] actions (or lack thereof) were, as she admits, a serious mistake in judgement, we cannot conclude they rose to the level of criminal recklessness.”

The mother then appealed her Endangering the Welfare of a Child conviction to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. In May 2020, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted the mother’s appeal and agreed to consider one single issue: “Was the evidence sufficient to establish beyond a reasonable doubt, that [the mother] knowingly endangered the welfare of her daughter when she put her in the back seat of a car for hire without a seat belt or restraint system, and there is no indicia that the driver was driving unsafely?”

On appeal, the Supreme Court reversed the Superior Court’s decision and overturned the mother’s endangering the welfare of her daughter’s conviction. The court rejected the lower court’s decision that the prosecutor only had to prove the mother was aware of her duty of care when taking her child for a ride in a rideshare vehicle. Instead, the court found the prosecution was required to prove that the mother was aware her conduct endangered the child’s welfare.

The court decided that the mother’s decision to allow her child to ride in a rideshare vehicle that was not equipped with a car seat, without other indicia of dangerousness, was not sufficient to put the mother on notice that her child’s welfare was being endangered. Ultimately, with several concurring opinions by other justices, the mother’s remaining conviction was thrown out.

One justice disagreed and argued that the mother’s failure to take any action to secure her child while riding in the rideshare vehicle was sufficient to support an endangering conviction.

Educate your family with rideshare safety tips to enjoy a smooth experience with Uber and Lyft!

If you are injured in a rideshare accident, consult with the attorneys at Metzger Wickersham to consider your options. We will answer your questions and provide legal advice during a no-cost case evaluation. Call us at (888)-286-2850 or email us to schedule your free consultation today.

Source: Commonwealth v. Howard, Pennsylvania Supreme Court, Case Number 21-1048

Categories
    I would recommend these people to anyone.

    “The lawyers at this office and their staff, Mr. [Attorney] DeVere and [Paralegal] Stephanie, his assistant, became the voice I didn’t have after the accident. They were my points of light.”

    - Ms. D. Lopez
    I would recommend Metzger Wickersham to everyone.

    “You guys were so easy to work with. There was no stress and the whole process was done in a timely manner. I would recommend Metzger Wickersham to everyone. Such a pleasure.”

    - Sharon Balent
    You guys are absolutely amazing and that’s an understatement.

    “Attorney Painter was simply amazing...My wife had been fighting SSI for over three years. Since working with Metzger Wickersham her stress and anxiety levels were 100% gone.”

    - Carlos Bonilla
    Outstanding in every way

    “Outstanding in every way no one has ever helped me more in my entire life like this firm. I highly recommend. Thank you very much.”

    - Gary Klinger
    Absolutely wonderful!

    “They helped me with my case on a motor vehicle accident. They were kind, understanding, professional, and got the job done. They explained things, talked me through stuff, and answered any questions I had!”

    - Ms. Brianna Marquis
    Thank you for going that extra mile.

    “I wanted to thank Valerie for all her hard work and going that extra mile for me! I was denied twice, Valerie appealed my case to the Appeals court. Thanks to Valerie, my case was finally won after ...”

    - Joanne Brenizer
    They made everything stress free.

    “They handle everything from the day you call, strongly recommend this office in particular. They made everything stress free and worked hard to get me what I deserved.”

    - Alexia Brodbeck
    I have nothing but good things to say!

    “Everyone here was very helpful and worked very hard. I have nothing but good things to say about Metzger Wickersham. Also I did want to mention that Andrea and Brad were amazing.”

    - Thomas Claytor
    They were always on top of things.

    “I was in a car accident last year, and contacted them after asking friends for recommendations. The entire experience was emotional and traumatizing, but they were always on top of things and were ...”

    - Jessica P.
    Absolutely the best!

    “They are absolutely the best! They care and are truly experts! Highly recommend!”

    - Cheryl Ressler

Let Us Fight For You

Request a Free Consultation
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.